In an era of intense societal discussions, a transgender attorney for the American Civil Liberties Union has emerged as a key figure. Chase Strangio, in an interview with CNN's Jake Tapper on Tuesday, has sparked a heated debate by advocating for sex change surgery for children while also acknowledging the complexity of consent at such a young age. This case, involving Tennessee's ban on "trans youth health care" including surgeries and puberty blockers, will be argued before the Supreme Court later this week. It raises crucial questions about the rights and well-being of transgender minors.
Chase Strangio's Perspective on the Ongoing Challenge
When Tapper asked how Strangio would respond to those concerned about the medical treatment for gender-questioning youths, Strangio firmly insisted that there is ample supporting data. He claimed that even kids as young as 10 or even younger are in dire need of "relief" from the suffering they endure. Strangio emphasized that these are not doctors being forced to provide the medication; rather, they are doctors who want to treat their patients in the best way based on the available evidence.Even toddlers, according to Strangio, are capable of being aware of their gender identities. However, it is important to note that minors cannot legally consent to medical procedures. Strangio acknowledged this protection while also trying to balance it with the rights of parents. He said, "And these are young people who may have known since they were two years old exactly who they are, who suffered for six or seven years before they had any relief."In cases where children do go through with gender reassignment surgery, Strangio made it clear that the decision ultimately lies with parents. He stated, "It’s not the kids who are consenting to this treatment. It’s the parents who are consenting to the treatment." Strangio further warned that if the Supreme Court sides with Tennessee, it could set a dangerous precedent that could lead to bans on transgender treatments for adults. He said, "And as a parent, I would say when our children are suffering, we are suffering."US v. Skrmetti will be the first time the high court considers restrictions on puberty blockers, hormone therapy, and surgery for minors. Strangio asserts that if Tennessee's ban is allowed to stand, it will have far-reaching consequences. He said, "I think that‘s one of the things we should be really concerned about. We‘re hearing a lot about young people can‘t consent to this care, but it is their parents consenting to this care. And at the end of the day, we have adults who live as transgender people, people like myself, who have families who are part of communities, who are part of this society. And if the incoming administration bans our health care, that is essentially excising us from this country."The Volunteer State is one of more than 20 US states that have moved to restrict access to gender transition medical treatments for minors. This ongoing battle highlights the need for a more comprehensive and nuanced discussion about the rights and well-being of transgender individuals at all ages.