Notre Dame's Playoff Controversy: From Ugly Loss to Ideal Seed

Nov 20, 2024 at 2:37 AM
Notre Dame's journey in the College Football Playoff has been a topic of much debate. After a shocking loss to Northern Illinois, many questioned whether the Irish would even make the playoff. But here we are, with Notre Dame ranked No. 6 and potentially set to host a first-round game.

The Golden Dome's Magical Playoff Impact

Recovering from the Loss

Notre Dame's ability to swiftly and effectively bounce back from that home turf loss to an average MAC opponent is truly remarkable. The Irish defense has shown its mettle, and Riley Leonard has found his footing in his first season with the new squad. Their 16-13 home loss to Northern Illinois seems to have been all but forgotten.After that setback, the Irish went on to have a great opening win against Texas A&M and a dominant performance against Navy. This recovery has impressed the College Football Playoff selection committee, as stated by chairman Warde Manuel.

Strength of Schedule and Rankings

It's interesting to note that while other playoff contenders scheduled a minimum of nine Power Four opponents, Notre Dame scheduled only eight. They will play only three true road games, with one coming against Purdue, which is 1-9. In contrast, every other team in playoff contention will play more road games.The seven Power Four opponents Notre Dame faced so far have a combined record of 30-40. They have blown out mediocre and bad opponents, with their road win at Texas A&M serving as a crown jewel. However, the issue remains whether a quality season-opening road win should be enough to secure a first-round host status.Notre Dame ranks ahead of teams like Alabama, Mississippi, and Georgia, despite having a trailing strength of schedule compared to every single SEC team in playoff contention.

Playoff Seeding and Implications

If the playoff started today, Notre Dame would be seeded No. 8 and host the No. 9 seed. But with teams ahead of them likely to lose in conference championship games or other matchups, their seeding could climb. A No. 5 seed would be the best Notre Dame is eligible to receive, as top-four seeds are reserved for conference champions.The Irish have games remaining against undefeated Army and at Southern California, which will be tough tests. A loss in either of these games could eliminate them from the playoff, opening up a spot for Tennessee. But a win would put them in a favorable position.Let's wait and see how it all unfolds on the field. The golden dome seems to have worked its magic once again, but the outcome remains uncertain.