Unraveling the 2024 NL Cy Young Ballot with Sale and Wheeler

Chris Sale's Dominance

Sale's dominance was on full display this season. His ability to consistently keep hitters at bay was remarkable. His low ERA and FIP indicated his exceptional control and command on the mound. The fact that he led the NL in strikeouts further showcased his dominance. His performance was not just a one-off but a consistent display throughout the season.

Even in a year where the Braves faced numerous injuries, Sale remained a constant. His consistency was a key factor in the team's performance. However, back spasms in the final days of the season forced him out of the rotation and kept him out of Atlanta's Wild Card loss at San Diego. Despite this setback, his season was still a standout.

Zack Wheeler's Fantastic Season

Zack Wheeler also had a fantastic season. He led the NL in WHIP with 0.955 and hits per nine innings with 6.3. Staying healthy throughout the entire season and making 32 starts, hitting an even 200.0 innings, was a testament to his durability.

Wheeler's numbers were impressive, but when compared to Sale, it was difficult to see where he would elevate himself over the dominant pitcher. Both pitchers had their strengths, but Sale's overall performance seemed to edge him out.

My Ballot Picks and Their Significance

Placing Zack Wheeler second on my ballot felt like the highest I could place the Philadelphia right-hander. His season was outstanding, but Sale's dominance made it hard to justify a higher placement.

My picks in the third through fifth slots caused some angst among fans, especially those in Pittsburgh. However, each pick was based on a careful analysis of the pitchers' performances. These three pitchers rounded out my 2024 NL Cy Young ballot for specific reasons that I will now explain.