Revisiting the 2025 Saints Draft: A Year Later, How Do They Stack Up?
Assessing the Foundation: Kelvin Banks, Offensive Lineman
Selecting Kelvin Banks as the ninth overall pick might not have been a headline-grabbing move, but it has proven to be a strategic triumph for the Saints. Banks showcased remarkable consistency, starting all seventeen games at left tackle and surrendering only five sacks. While his debut season wasn't flawless, he solidified his position as a crucial protector for the quarterback's blind side, forming a formidable partnership with Taliese Fuaga for years to come. His performance earns a solid B+ grade.
Unveiling the Quarterback's Potential: Tyler Shough, Signal-Caller
The choice of Tyler Shough at pick 40 initially drew criticism, yet it turned out to be an unexpected success for the Saints. In his nine starts, Shough guided the team to a 5-4 record, transforming the team's outlook from skepticism to renewed hope. While it's premature to declare him a franchise quarterback, his immediate impact and promising trajectory are undeniable. This pick is worthy of an A grade.
The Unseen Talent: Vernon Broughton, Defensive Lineman
Vernon Broughton's rookie season was unfortunately cut short by an injury in his very first game, leaving fans with little to assess. Consequently, his 2026 season will be pivotal as he aims to carve out a role within the Saints' competitive defensive line. Given the circumstances, a negative grade would be unfair at this stage. He receives a C-.
The Rising Star in the Secondary: Jonas Sanker, Safety
Jonas Sanker was thrust into a more prominent role than anticipated after Julian Blackmon's season-ending injury in Week 1. Sanker not only met the challenge but excelled in his expanded duties. He is now slated to transition to the STAR position, a critical role in Brandon Staley's defensive scheme. Sanker's bright future in the Saints' defense earns him an A- grade.
The Linebacker's Promise: Danny Stutsman, Linebacker
Danny Stutsman's prowess against the run was evident during his rookie campaign, though his struggles in pass coverage limited his playing time. However, he is poised for a breakout year as he steps into the shoes of veteran Demario Davis. Stutsman is expected to see significant minutes and play a pivotal role in the defense's overall success. He receives a C+.
The Quiet Contributor: Quincy Riley, Cornerback
Quincy Riley's rookie season was not marked by flashy plays, but he quietly contributed as a valuable asset, particularly in the later stages of the season. The cornerback is set for a substantial opportunity in 2026, projected to start opposite Kool-Aid McKinstry. Should he continue his development, his grade could see a significant bump next year. He earns a B.
The Reliable Depth: Devin Neal, Running Back
Devin Neal's career has been hampered by injuries, yet he remains a strong contender for the third-string running back position. He proved to be a dependable option in relief last season and has the potential to be a quality depth piece if he can maintain his health. He receives a C+.
The Developmental Prospect: Moliki Matavao, Tight End
Moliki Matavao saw limited action in his rookie season, primarily spending time on the practice squad. While the coaching staff clearly believes in his potential by keeping him on the roster, his path to a significant role is challenging with Juwan Johnson, Oscar Delp, and Noah Fant ahead of him on the depth chart. He receives a D+.
The Emerging Edge Rusher: Fadil Diggs, Defensive End
Similar to Matavao, Fadil Diggs saw minimal defensive snaps, totaling just 54. However, his potential for a larger role in the Saints' edge rush unit is more apparent. A strong training camp could lead to a significant increase in playing time this season. He earns a C-.
